Season 2 Tank Tier List: Best Tanks in World of Warcraft The War Within

Choosing the right tank is crucial for dominating dungeons and raids in World of Warcraft: The War Within Season 2.

With new tuning changes, reworked talents, and shifting class balance, the meta has evolved—catapulting some tanks far above the rest.

Whether you’re leading your raid to progression or pushing high-level Mythic+ keys, knowing the landscape of tanking this season will give your group the edge it needs.

In this comprehensive guide, we break down the best tanks for The War Within Season 2, analyzing each spec's strengths, weaknesses, and ideal use cases to help you confidently anchor your team in any content.

---

Understanding the Tank Tier List: Criteria and Methodology

Creating a reliable tank tier list for The War Within Season 2 involves much more than anecdotal ranking.

Tank power is determined by a mix of hard performance data, meta analysis, and community expertise.

Here are the main criteria used in this evaluation:

Key Ranking Criteria

1. Survivability (Defensive Capability)
   • What matters: Passive and active mitigation, self-healing, cooldowns, and performance against common damage types (physical/magic) across current dungeons and raids.
2. Utility
   • What matters: Unique party/raid tools (battle res, group damage reduction, crowd control, movement utility).
3. Damage Output
   • What matters: Tank DPS in AoE and single-target scenarios, critical for threat and overall group performance at high keys.
4. Popularity and Meta Representation
   • What matters: How frequently tanks appear in high Mythic+ keys or progression raids—reflecting not only raw power but group trust and perceived value.
5. Adaptability and Meta Relevance
   • What matters: Ability to handle new mechanics, synergy with top DPS/heal specs, and flexibility in varied encounters.

How Tanks Are Scored

Composite scoring methods, informed by both expert and community sources, rate tanks 1–5 across perception, damage, defense, and utility.

Data sources like Warcraft Logs, Raider.IO stats, and feedback from top tier guides and forum experts (see sources) ensure rankings reflect both live results and theoretical power.

Expert Insight:
*"Tanks are reasonably close together when it comes to defensive power.

Defensively, every tank is 100% viable.

The major differences ... are damage output, utility, and unique buffs."*

— Icy Veins

---

S and A Tier Tanks: The Strongest Picks for Season 2

Patch 11.1’s talent reworks and tier set changes have shaken up the tanking landscape for The War Within Season 2—especially for high-end Mythic+ and heroic/raid content.

Here, we spotlight the meta-defining tanks that set the bar for performance and group utility.

S-Tier Tanks

Vengeance Demon Hunter (VDH)

• Why S-tier:
  • Top pick for Mythic+ due to best-in-slot AoE, superb self-healing, and crowd control.
  • Meta-defining combination: High sustain, mob control (Sigil toolkit), Chaos Brand debuff (+3% magic dmg raid/party-wide), and group-wide emergency avoidance (Darkness).
  • Community representation: Most seen in high keys and meta groups.
• Where VDH shines:
  Dungeons with high caster density, raid compositions missing Havoc DH, or any scenario needing meta uptime and AoE threat.

Protection Warrior

• Why S-tier:
  • Major buffs in Patch 11.1 (talent overhaul, Ignore Pain, rage management, damage).
  • Top non-healer raid cooldown with Rallying Cry, robust party buffs (Battle Shout), and improved mobility/control.
  • High damage: Often leads tank DPS meters in both AoE and ST situations.
• Where Prot Warrior shines:
  Content requiring flexible damage, raid cooldowns, or strong group buffs—favored in both progression and high Mythic+.

Blood Death Knight (Raid S-tier)

• Why S-tier in raid:
  • Best self-sustain: Cooldown planning + Death Strike = near-immortality on most encounters.
  • Utility: AoE mass grip (Abomination Limb), Anti-Magic Zone (group magic DR), Death Grip.
  • Patch changes: Massive damage buffs, reworked hero talents.
• Caveat:
  Much stronger in raids (single-target, add control value) than in large Mythic+ pulls.

Lower overall DPS but unparalleled survivability.

Protection Paladin (Borderline S/A Tier)

• Why top tier:
  • Unrivaled utility: Auras, Lay on Hands, Blessings (Protection, Spellwarding, Sacrifice), top-tier external cooldown coverage.
  • Reliable self-healing, shield-based mitigation, and group buffs.
  • Patch context: Nerfed slightly (DPS/durability) but remains meta-staple, especially for PUGs and progression groups.
• Where Prot Paladin shines:
  Raid or dungeon groups needing utility stacking, debuff immunities, or robust support for weaker healers.

A-Tier Tanks

Guardian Druid

• Big improvements in DPS and movement (with Stampeding Roar, Mark of the Wild) from talent rework, but still less durable in high-key magic-intensive content.
• Especially effective in mobile fights or with Druid utility gaps in the group.

Brewmaster Monk

• High-demand debuff (Mystic Touch) and strong damage potential when played perfectly.
• Suffers from low self-sustain and high complexity—solid in raids, but less forgiving in Mythic+ without a dedicated healer.

---

Meta Analysis:
"The new Mythic+ dungeon pool and affixes benefit tanks with superior AoE utility and reliable self-healing, solidifying VDH and Prot Paladin/Warrior at the top."
— Icy Veins

---

B and Lower Tiers: Viable Options and Underperformers

Despite clear domination by a handful of tanks, B and below-tier specs are far from unplayable.

They offer valuable niche utility, class flavor, and are "100% viable" outside the most punishing content.

Here's where they stand:

Guardian Druid (B+ in Mythic+, A in Raiding)

• Pros:
  Stampeding Roar (movement), Innervate, Mark of the Wild, ST damage.
• Cons:
  Less durable in larger Mythic+ pulls; utility duplicable by other Druids.
• When to choose:
  If another Druid spec isn’t present, or for raids prioritizing movement utility.

Brewmaster Monk (B+ M+, B/A Raid)

• Pros:
  High physical damage reduction (Stagger), party debuff (Mystic Touch), strong control tools (Ring of Peace).
• Cons:
  High skill/barrier of entry due to rotation, lowest self-heal, more healer reliance.
• When to choose:
  For fun, group comp needs, or if you enjoy challenge/high-reward playstyle.

Blood Death Knight (C/B in M+, A in Raid)

• Pros:
  Best add control, single-target tanking, and anti-magic tools.
• Cons:
  DPS and raw mitigation suffer in high Mythic+ AoE; new tier set is RNG-based.
• When to choose:
  Lower key content, progression raids, or when group needs grips/mass magic reduction.

---

Takeaway:
"The skill of the player often matters more than the specific tank pick for most content below the race-to-world-first or highest Mythic+ realms."
— Icy Veins

---

Tips for Choosing and Playing Your Tank in The War Within

The optimal tank for you is more than just a meta snapshot—it should blend group needs, encounter requirements, and your personal comfort.

Here’s how to make the best choice and master any tank you play:

**1.

Match Your Tank to Your Group and Content**

• Fill missing buffs/debuffs (e.g., Chaos Brand, Battle Shout).
• Consider encounter demands: is the fight more magic-heavy, AoE-intensive, or movement-focused?
• Play what you enjoy; comfort breeds performance—the "B-tier" tank in the hands of an expert often outperforms a novice on S-tier.

**2.

Gearing and Talents**

• Flexible builds: Adjust talents for each dungeon/raid—trade defense for offense where possible, and vice versa.
• Trinkets and gear: Carry options for burst mitigation vs. sustained fights; focus on secondary stats favored by your spec.
• Key talents to watch:
  • Prot Warrior: Shield Block, Ignore Pain, Demoralizing Shout, Mountain Thane.
  • VDH: Fiery Brand, Sigil mastery, Soul Rending.
  • Blood DK: Bonestorm, Death Strike focus.
  • Prot Pally: Sentinel, Bulwark of Order, Blessings suite.

**3.

Addons and Awareness**

• Use threat meters, nameplate mods, and cooldown trackers.
• Familiarize yourself with boss/add spawns, mob mechanics, and optimal pull/route strategies.

**4.

Leadership and Teamwork**

• The tank sets the pace and leads pulls—clear communication on marks, movement, and cooldown usage is critical.
• Work with your healer(s) on defensive timing; coordinate external cooldowns and communicate before big pulls or damage spikes.

**5.

Practice, Practice, Practice**

• Tanking is about confidence, encounter repetition, and learning through trial and error.

As you master routes and timings, your performance (and confidence) will skyrocket.

---

Conclusion

No matter where your favorite tank falls on the Season 2 tier list, knowledge and preparation trump raw class rankings for 99% of WoW players.

S-tier tanks (Vengeance Demon Hunter, Protection Warrior, Blood Death Knight, and Protection Paladin) clearly dominate the meta thanks to their exceptional balance of personal durability, group utility, and DPS—but every tank can find success in the right hands and group.

Season 2 of The War Within offers exciting depth and flexibility for ambitious tank players.

Choose the spec that matches your favorite playstyle, cover your group’s needs, and lead your party to victory.

After all—while the meta defines the top, skillful play and teamwork define success.

---

Sources

• Icy Veins — Mythic+ Tank Rankings
• Icy Veins — Raiding Tank Tier List
• U.GG — War Within Tank Rankings
• WoW Forums — AI Research Assistant on Tank Tuning
• Method Nate — Tank Tier List Video
• Wowhead — Season 2 Mythic+ Rewards
• Murlok.io Meta: Season 2 Tank Tier List

Relevant images used with attribution to Blizzard and major community resources.

---

Now gather your shield, rally your party, and become the unbreakable bulwark your team needs in The War Within Season 2!